Why Succession Planning is a Waste of Time, but You Should Do It Anyway

In the fast-paced corporate world, succession planning often feels like an exercise in futility.

Why meticulously map out future leadership transitions when the unpredictable nature of business can render these plans obsolete overnight? Yet, despite its apparent lack of worth, succession planning remains a critical process that organisations cannot afford to neglect.

The Futility of Succession Planning

One of the primary frustrations with succession planning is the inherent unpredictability of both business landscapes and human behaviour.

Market dynamics can shift rapidly, rendering the skills and attributes of pre-selected successors irrelevant. Additionally, potential successors may leave the organisation, lose interest or fail to develop as expected. This makes the entire process seem like a pointless attempt to control the uncontrollable.

Moreover, the traditional models of succession planning often focus too heavily on a linear progression of roles, failing to account for the more fluid and dynamic career paths that are becoming increasingly common.

Employees today seek varied experiences and may not be content with a predefined path, further complicating the planning process.

Why Succession Planning is Still Necessary

Despite these challenges, the act of succession planning is invaluable. Here’s why:

1. Organisational Stability

Succession planning provides a safety net that ensures business continuity in the face of unexpected leadership changes. By having a pool of prepared candidates, organisations can transition more smoothly during periods of change, reducing the risk of disruption to operations.

2. Talent Development

A robust succession plan is essentially a framework for talent development. It highlights the competencies and experiences that future leaders need, guiding employee development programmes. This not only prepares individuals for higher responsibilities but also fosters a culture of continuous learning and growth.

3. Employee Engagement and Retention

Employees are more likely to stay with an organisation that invests in their future. Succession planning demonstrates a commitment to internal promotion and career progression, which can significantly boost morale and engagement. When employees see a clear path to advance along, their loyalty to the organisation increases.

4. Strategic Alignment

Effective succession planning aligns leadership development with the organisation’s strategic goals. By identifying future leaders who embody the desired culture and values, organisations can ensure that their strategic vision is upheld. This alignment is crucial for long-term success and can provide a competitive edge.

Practical Tips for Effective Succession Planning

Given the complexities and potential pitfalls of succession planning, how can a business maximise its effectiveness? Here are some practical tips:

1. Foster a Culture of Agility

Encourage a mindset that embraces change and adaptability. This involves developing leaders who are not only skilled but also resilient and capable of navigating uncertainty. By focusing on these traits, organisations can build a leadership pipeline that is better suited to handle the unexpected.

2. Use a Broad Perspective

Rather than relying solely on linear career progression, consider a more holistic approach. Look at potential leaders across different functions and levels within the organisation. This can help identify hidden talents and diversify the leadership pool.

3. Regularly Review and Update Plans

Succession plans should be dynamic documents that evolve with the organisation. Regular reviews ensure that the plans remain relevant and aligned with the current business environment and strategic objectives.

4. Integrate with Overall Talent Management

Succession planning should not be a standalone process. Integrate it with broader talent management strategies, including recruitment, performance management, and learning and development. This creates a cohesive approach to building a strong leadership pipeline.

5. Make it an explicit requirement of the current leadership

Great leaders beget more great leaders. Average leaders beget terrible or no leaders at all. Ensure that you’re building the succession pipeline with incredibly talented leaders who may get promoted if the opportunity arises but who, failing that, will still add lots of value to the business.

Conclusion

While succession planning may often feel like a futile exercise, its benefits far outweigh the frustrations. By ensuring organisational stability, fostering talent development, enhancing employee engagement and aligning with strategic goals, succession planning becomes an indispensable part of a thriving business. Embrace the process, adapt it to your organisation’s unique needs, and watch as it transforms potential challenges into opportunities for growth.

Exigence provides a full suite of evidence-based business coaching solutions, driven by a desire to help individuals and teams to achieve their performance potential. Find out more here or book a call to talk through how we can support you.

Verified by MonsterInsights