Somewhere in the middle of your body, your gut microbiome is quietly shaping your health. It processes nutrients, regulates immunity, and influences everything from your energy levels to mental clarity. Feed it well, manage stress, and move your body, and it thrives. Neglect it, and it becomes a breeding ground for dysfunction, weakening the entire system.
The same is true for the middle of your organisation.
Your middle managers—the team leaders, department heads, and regional directors—form the gut microbiome of your business. When well-supported, they drive execution, foster culture, and spark innovation. But, if neglected, they become a bottleneck, stifling energy, blocking progress, and turning your organisational core into a toxic, dysfunctional space.
Middle Leaders: The Unsung Engine of Your Business
Middle leaders are often viewed as conduits between executives and front-line teams. But they are far more than just messengers. Research shows they play a pivotal role in organisational effectiveness, acting as the linchpin that turns strategy into execution (Balogun, 2021). Their positioning allows them to influence multiple critical areas:
1. Culture Carriers
Middle managers shape the daily employee experience more than any CEO ever could. They translate corporate values into real behaviours, shaping how people interact, collaborate, and make decisions (Caldwell et al., 2022).
2. Operational Enablers
Strategy means nothing without execution, and middle leaders are the ones making it happen. They align teams, remove barriers, and keep the organisation moving forward (Floyd & Wooldridge, 2020).
3. Innovation Catalysts
Being close to both customers and technical work, middle managers are ideally positioned to spot inefficiencies and drive innovation. Yet many organisations fail to leverage this potential, focusing innovation efforts only at senior levels or frontline teams (Huy, 2023).
4. Talent Developers
Perhaps most critically, middle leaders shape career paths. They are the primary developers of future leadership, influencing engagement, retention, and professional growth (Gagné et al., 2022). A disengaged middle layer can stifle careers, while a well-supported one can accelerate them.
When Middle Management Turns Toxic
Just as an unhealthy gut can cause fatigue, inflammation, and long-term disease, a neglected middle management tier can quietly erode an organisation’s strength. Common symptoms of organisational ‘gut dysfunction’ include:
- High turnover and disengagement – Poorly equipped middle managers lead to frustrated teams, driving talent away.
- Bureaucratic bottlenecks – When middle leaders lack empowerment, they become blockers rather than enablers.
- Strategic drift – Without strong middle leadership, execution loses focus, and strategies fail in practice.
How to Nurture a Healthy Organisational Core
A thriving gut microbiome requires the right nutrients, stress management, and movement. Likewise, a thriving middle leadership layer needs:
Investment in development – Training must go beyond technical skills to include leadership, coaching, and strategic thinking.
Empowerment and autonomy – Middle managers need decision-making authority to drive real impact.
Clear career pathways – Organisations that prioritise middle leadership development retain talent and build future executives.
The lesson is clear: if you want a healthy organisation, start with your middle. Are you feeding your organisational gut what it needs to thrive—or letting dysfunction take hold?
—
Bibliography
Balogun, J. (2021). Middle Managers and Strategy: Micro-Dynamics of Execution. Oxford University Press.
Caldwell, R., Chatman, J., & O’Reilly, C. (2022). The Role of Middle Managers in Culture Execution. Academy of Management Review, 47(2), 205-220.
Floyd, S. W., & Wooldridge, B. (2020). Building Strategy from the Middle: Reconceptualizing Strategy Process. Journal of Management, 46(3), 559-582.
Gagné, M., Morin, A., & Fang, C. (2022). The Power of Middle Managers in Employee Development. Journal of Applied Psychology, 107(8), 1245-1261.
Huy, Q. N. (2023). Middle Managers as Innovation Brokers: Unlocking Organisational Creativity. MIT Sloan Management Review, 64(1), 34-41.
Exigence provides a full suite of evidence-based business coaching solutions, driven by a desire to help individuals and teams to achieve their performance potential. Find out more here or contact us to talk through how we can support you.
